Advertisement
Advertisement
Japan
Get more with myNEWS
A personalised news feed of stories that matter to you
Learn more
Residents of a quake-hit area wait for food distribution at a shelter in Anamizu, Ishikawa prefecture on Sunday. More than 160 Japanese lost their lives in the earthquake that struck on New Year’s Day. Photo: Kyodo News via AP

Japanese hit out at ‘completely crazy’ Ukraine aid in deadly Japan earthquake’s aftermath

  • Criticism of Japan’s aid to Ukraine has intensified after the quake, reflecting a shift away from unconditional support for the besieged nation
  • But others remain adamant that Japan must remain a reliable international partner – in case it too needs help in the event of a military attack
Japan
Japanese Foreign Minister Yoko Kamikawa’s surprise visit to Ukraine on Sunday saw her assure President Volodymyr Zelensky of Tokyo’s continued support in the war with Russia – but in her homeland there is a growing sense that the Japanese people are shifting away from unconditional backing for the besieged European nation.
Kamikawa’s visit, during which she promised Japan would provide Ukraine with US$37 million for an advanced drone-detection system and additional generators, was covered extensively by the Japanese media. It followed Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida pledging US$4.5 billion to Ukraine last month, including US$1 billion in humanitarian aid to support recovery efforts.

As recently as October, a survey released by international consultancy GlobeScan showed that 77 per cent of Japanese people agreed with their government supporting Ukraine. But dissent appears to be growing after the latest pledges.

Ukraine’s President Volodymyr Zelensky and Japan’s Foreign Minister Yoko Kamikawa in Kyiv, Ukraine, on Sunday. Photo: Ukrainian Presidential Press Service/Handout via Reuters
Those criticisms appear to have worsened significantly in the aftermath of the magnitude-7.6 earthquake that struck the Noto peninsula on January 1, leaving at least 202 dead and more than 100 still missing.

An online article by Jiji Press on Tuesday attracted a number of negative comments, with one asking: “What is the Japanese government doing in a place like this when so many people on the Noto peninsula are fighting cold and hunger? The US has begun withdrawing from Ukraine. Japan has been left behind and forced to look after Ukraine instead of the Noto peninsula.”

Another wrote: “Delivering aid money to Ukraine, which is refusing to stop a war that kills people while ignoring the helpless people of Noto, who are trapped in the rubble! It is clearly harmful to the national interest.”

Echoing the sentiment of conservatives in many countries, including Republicans in the United States, a post on the JapanToday website said: “This is completely crazy and stupid. Why [does] Japan want to waste US$37 million in a war that doesn’t belong to Japan?

“Look at the disaster of the earthquake, the elderly, the children. Japanese people need ASAP those US$37 million in government help instead [of the] Kyiv regime.”

Other messages have theorised that much of the aid funds are being siphoned off by corrupt government officials in Ukraine, with one poster claiming to have proof that a senior member of Zelensky’s administration spent millions of dollars on a house in Germany.

03:03

Woman in her 90s miraculously survives 5 days buried under Japan earthquake rubble

Woman in her 90s miraculously survives 5 days buried under Japan earthquake rubble

A Ukrainian national living in Japan, who asked not to be named, told This Week in Asia he had noticed waning interest in the conflict among his Japanese friends and colleagues.

“My sense is that they are getting tired of being involved in something that could go on and on for a long time,” he said. “There was enthusiasm for the resistance at the beginning, but when it becomes a long and hard struggle, then people tend to think of their own problems first.

“I do understand, but it would be nice if people would be a little more supportive,” he said. “I think it is possible that if something really bad happened again, then some support would come back, but if the war just continues as it is now, then I think it will be hard to generate any new support.”

For me, we have to continue to support Kyiv because … it’s our war as well, they are just the ones fighting it
Ken Kato, Japanese politician and businessman

Yakov Zinberg, a Russia-born professor of international relations at Tokyo’s Kokushikan University, said he had also sensed a change in attitudes among Japanese people.

“When I speak to my friends and students, there has been a clear change,” he said. “Many believe that Ukraine will not be successful, and they ask why we should send money to Kyiv when we have problems here in Japan.

“That has become far more common since the earthquake and many people are saying that Tokyo has sent far too little to the disaster zone,” he added.

Zinberg said the attitudes of many Japanese were comparable to conservatives in the US, where the debate has focused on preventing migrants from crossing the southern border illegally rather than spending money on weapons for Ukraine.

03:42

Ukraine says Russian strike killed over 50 in one of the deadliest attacks of the war

Ukraine says Russian strike killed over 50 in one of the deadliest attacks of the war

“I can see Russia’s hand behind all this debate,” Zinberg said. “The right-wing has been convinced to oppose efforts to support Ukraine and now those on the far left are saying the same things, even if it is for very different reasons.”

Others, however, are adamant that Japan needs to stand by Ukraine if it wants to be seen as a reliable partner, and because there may come a time when the Japanese people need similar assistance to fend off a military challenge.

“I am surprised to hear Japanese people saying we should abandon Ukraine because that is not what I am hearing from my friends and business contacts,” said Ken Kato, a politically conservative businessman from Tokyo and member of the ruling Liberal Democratic Party.

Firefighters search for missing people on Monday as snow blankets parts of the disaster-hit area in the city of Suzu on the Noto peninsula, a week after a 7.5-magnitude earthquake struck the region. Photo: Jiji Press / AFP

“For me, we have to continue to support Kyiv because … it’s our war as well, they are just the ones fighting it,” he said.

“I have not seen any public opinion polls on the issue, but we have to remember that Russia broke its treaty with Japan in 1945 and invaded Japanese islands in the far north before the surrender.”

Kato said he had “no trust” in the promises of President Vladimir Putin and the Kremlin could have additional territorial claims against Japan. “Russia is a threat to Japan and if it is not faced down by the international community now, there is an even bigger danger in the future.”

If Russia were not defeated, Putin would be able to claim a victory that humiliated the West, Kato said, adding that such an outcome “would be very dangerous because it would show others that they can ignore international law and do as they wish”.

The danger was particularly acute in the Western Pacific, he said, as failure to resist Russian advances in Ukraine could embolden mainland China to invade Taiwan.

“An invasion [of Taiwan] would inevitably affect Japan and I would hope that the global community would stand by us,” Kato said.

“I find it hard to believe that some Japanese are so short-sighted they cannot see this, especially when Japan is sufficiently wealthy and resilient to both support Ukraine and help the people of the Noto peninsula.”

29